|
A Portrait
of Refugees That Transcends Words
By ALAN RIDING
| PARIS, July 7 —
During her four decades as an experimental theater
director, Ariane Mnouchkine has never doubted
the power of the stage to carry a message. She
has also never lacked an audience eager to hear
it, whether at festivals or at Théâtre
du Soleil's sprawling home on the outskirts of
Paris. Yet for all her devotion to worthy causes,
at age 64 her acute sense of theater continues
to prevail. |
 |
This is again the case with her latest
production, "Le Dernier Caravansérail
(Odysées)," or "The Last Caravanserai
(Odyssey)," which has been playing here since
April and will return in the fall. It is programmed
for the Avignon theater festival this month. (Cultural
sector workers are threatening to disrupt the festival's
opening on Wednesday.)
In this show her theme is the plight
of refugees, her unsurprising message that they deserve
compassion and understanding. But how this is conveyed
is anything but predictable. In a succession of fast-moving
and highly stylized scenes, actors re-enact critical
moments in the lives of, in the main, Middle Eastern
and Asian refugees. The only décor are the
props for each scene. Few words are spoken (and those
are often not in French). Yet the effect communicates
the fear and violence that besiege many refugees as
they flee their homes and trek to safer lands.
The subject is particularly topical
in Western Europe. Increasing numbers of illegal immigrants
and asylum seekers have boosted anti-immigration parties
in France, Denmark, the Netherlands and Austria. Until
an asylum camp near the French port of Calais was
closed last December, Britain complained that France
was indirectly encouraging refugees to sneak into
Britain aboard Channel tunnel trains. Australia too
has taken a hard line against illegal immigrants and
refugees.
The issue has also been taken up by
artists. It was addressed in 2000 by the photographer
Sebastião Salgado in "Migrations,"
a photo book and a traveling exhibition. The American
director Peter Sellars recently turned Euripides'
"Children of Herakles" into a commentary
on today's refugee crisis. And Michael Winterbottom's
new movie, "In This World," which won the
top prize in this year's Berlin film festival, follows
two Afghan refugees trying to reach Britain.
In "Le Dernier Caravansérail
(Odysées)" (a "caravanserai"
is an Eastern inn with an inner court where desert
caravans rest), Ms. Mnouchkine (pronounced muh-NOOSH-kin)
worked mainly with material gathered in 2001 from
refugees at the asylum camp of Sangatte near Calais.
Other interviews were held in camps in Australia,
New Zealand and Indonesia during a tour of her company's
last work, "The Flood Drummers," about the
social impact of damming the Yangtze River in China.
But rather than simply translate this
material to the stage, Ms. Mnouchkine first asked
actors to improvise scenes based on their imagination
and experience (with 22 nationalities represented
on the theater's staff, there was ample experience
to tap). Only after extensive improvisation did the
actors listen to the refugees' recorded testimonies.
Imagination was then tested against reality, before
101 "récits," or tales, were created.
So far only 19 of the "récits"
are in the show performed here and scheduled to be
seen in Avignon. "We originally intended to alternate
récits, but we saw that a loose but coherent
structure emerged, which gave force to the production,"
explained Charles-Henri Bradier, Ms. Mnouchkine's
assistant. "It would take many weeks to create
a similar ensemble. We may try to introduce new elements
in the fall."
The opening show borrows its subtitle,
"The Cruel River," from the first scene,
a stunning re-enactment of refugees trying to cross
a river separating Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan in Central
Asia. With a huge billowing stage-cloth and a loud
soundtrack portraying the stormy river and refugees
arguing with smugglers on either bank, the refugees
hold desperately onto a rope — one traveler
is lost — as they make the perilous crossing.
From this moment the pace of the production
never wavers. All the actors enter, perform and leave
on low wheeled platforms that are pushed swiftly and
silently by other actors or stagehands. Even the props
— a health clinic in Sangatte, a home in Kabul,
a telephone booth in Paris — are wheeled on
and off, creating both a fluidity of movement and
a reminder that this is theater's version of reality.
 |
Occasionally scenes are separated
by excerpts of letters or testimonies from refugees,
which are projected onto a back-cloth in French
and spoken in either Persian or Kurdish. The languages
of other refugees or of policemen, border guards
and smugglers — English, French, Italian,
Russian, Bulgarian and German — are also
used, with French subtitles appearing on a small
screen that pops up at the front of the stage. |
Scenes from countries of origin and
from the refugees' journeys are interwoven to stress
cause and effect. Kabul is still the Afghan capital
of the Taliban, where militiamen harass women and
fall upon a young couple making love: the woman is
next shown dead, either a suicide or executed. In
Teheran a young woman returns home from an antigovernment
demonstration and screams when her father embraces
her: her back is bloodied from being lashed.
In Sangatte a Kurd who has lost his
foot is given a metal crutch, which he then plays
like a flute; another refugee is caught with two women
he is abusing. Then, near the entrance to the Channel
tunnel, there are the nightly scenes — at least
until late last year when the camp was closed —
where refugees cut through wire fences and play hide-and-seek
with security guards as they await the signal from
smugglers to board a departing cargo train.
Some isolated moments are among the
most poignant. An elderly woman preparing to leave
Moscow bids farewell to her drunken homeless brother
slumped under a telephone booth; her final gift is
a small box containing his war medals. In Paris a
young woman calls home, and while her brother is too
depressed to speak, she reassures her distant parents
that they have been well received in France and now
live on the Champs-Élysées.
One scene helps explain the widespread
preference of many refugees to cross successive European
borders and gamble on reaching Britain. "My cousin
came off the train in London and was greeted by a
policeman," a refugee cheerfully reports by telephone
from London. "First he took him to Buckingham
Palace and then he said, `Would you like a job? A
house?' " In reality asylum-seekers in Britain
are kept in special residences until their applications
are processed.
Yet, for all the despair it evokes,
"Le Dernier Caravansérail (Odysées)"
neither points a finger of guilt at the West nor portrays
the refugees as invariably saintly. Rather, it takes
what can be read in daily newspapers and, through
the magnifying prism of theater, gives it a human
face. The depth of refugees' need to leave their homes,
it suggests, can be measured simply by what they will
endure to reach a new land.
The
New York Times
Julio
- 2003
|